Chapter 20
Carboxylic Acid Derivatives:
Nucleophilic Acyl Substitution
Chapter 20 suggested problems: none
Class Notes
- The functional derivatives of carboxylic acids
- Acyl group: R-CO-
- Closely related to each other and a number of other chemical
families
- Acyl chlorides
- Carboxylic acid anhydrides
- Carboxylic acid esters
- Amides (carboxamides)
- Nomenclature
- Acid halides: change "ic acid" to "yl halide"
- Propanoic acid to propanoyl chloride
- Acid anhydrides: change "acid" to anhydride
- Benzoic acid to benzoic anhydride
- Esters: change "ic acid" to "ate," preceded
by name of alcohol or phenol group
- Methyl ethanoate
- Amides: change "ic acid" of common name or "oic
acid" of IUPAC name to "amide"
- Acetamide and ethanamide
- Structure, electron delocalization, and resonance
- All of the acid derivatives feature an atom attached to
the acyl group with one or more lone pairs of electrons
- Electron release (of a non-bonding pair) by the substituent
results in resonance stabilization of the compound

- This stabilizes the carbonyl and decreases its electrophilic
character
- The extent of stabilization depends on the ability of the
substituent to share its non-bonding pairs
- In acid chlorides the long C-Cl bond length (180 pm) results
in poor orbital overlap and ineffective sharing of chlorine's
nbp

- At the same time, the EN of Cl effects electron distribution
on the carbonyl carbon, making it relatively more susceptible
to nucleophilic attack than the other acid derivatives
- Acid anhydrides are better stabilized than acyl chlorides
but the twin carbonyls both vie for the non-bonding pair

- Esters are better stabilized thna anhydrides because only
one carbonyl is competing for non-bonding pair

- Amides are better stabilized than esters

- Carboxylate ions exhibit the greatest resonance stabilization
of the acid derivatives

- One acid derivative can be converted to another if the conversion
results in a more stabilized carbonyl group
- Physical properties
- The acid derivatives are polar due to the carbonyl group
- BP
- Acid chlorides, anhydrides, and esters are similar to
comparably sized aldehydes and ketones
- Amides (1° & 2°) are capable of H-bonds and have
high BP
- Solubility
- Aqueous solubility: 3-5 carbons for esters, 5-6 carbons
for amides
- Varying solubility in other polar solvents
- Volatile esters have pleasant odors
- Nucleophilic acyl substitution
- Common denominators
- Each derivative is prepared (directly or indirectly) from
the corresponding carboxylic acid and can be converted back
by hydrolysis
- Much of the chemistry of these compounds involves the conversion
of the substances into their parent acids and into each other,
although each class also has its distinct reactions
- Acid derivatives retain the acid carbonyl group (although
it may be temporarily lost during transition states), which
determines the characteristic reactivity of these compounds
- The carbonyl group performs two functions
- It is the site of nucleophilic attack and addition
- It increases a-hydrogen acidity
- Acids and their derivatives undergo nucleophilic addition
in which -OH, -Cl, -OOCR, -NH2, or -OR' are replaced
by another Lewis base
- Substitution occurs with greater ease than at an sp3
hybridized carbon
- As is the case in aldehydes/ketones, both electronic and
steric factors enhance the relative reactivity of the carbonyl
carbon
- The tendency of the carbonyl oxygen to gain electrons,
even to the extent of becoming fully negatively charged
- The relatively unhindered transition from trigonal planar
to tetrahedral geometry (as compared to the transition from
tetravalent to pentavalent carbon in SN2 substitutions)
- A comparison of addition and substitution

- The reaction proceeds to a tetrahedral intermediate in
both cases
- Aldehydes/ketones add a nucleophile to the carbonyl carbon,
while acyl compounds undergo substitution
- The ease with which :W leaves depends both on its stability
and on its strength as a base: the weaker the base, the
better the leaving group
- For the acid derivatives the leaving groups are the very
weak base Cl-, the moderately weak base RCOO-,
and strong bases OH- and R'O-
- For an aldehyde/ketone to undergo substitution the leaving
group would have to be either a hydride ion (H-)
or an alkide (R-) group, so addition nearly always
happens and substitution almost never occurs
- Mechanism: two steps, rate affected by both steps but the
first step is the more important of the two

- The rate of the first step (from reactant to tetrahedral
intermediate) is enhanced by electron-withdrawing substituents
(on R) and can be hindered by electron-donating or bulky
substituents
- The rate of the second step depends on the basicity
of the leaving group (:W)
- Acid-catalyzed nucleophilic substitution is enhanced by
the protonation of the carbonyl, which makes the carbonyl
carbon even more susceptible to nucleophilic attack

- Nucleophilic substitution: alkyl vs. acyl
- The carbonyl group makes acyl compounds more reactive than
alkyl compounds
- This is largely a matter of transition state geometry
- The transition state of SN2 substitutions involves
a geometry change from tetrahedral to essentially trigonal
bipyramidal, which is unstable in carbon compounds
- The transition state of acyl substitutions involves a geometry
change from trigonal planar to tetrahedral geometry, both
of which are stable
- Nucleophilic substitution reactions of acyl chlorides
- With carboxylic acids to form acid anhydrides
- With alcohols to form ethers
- With ammonia and amines to form amides
- With water (hydrolysis) to form carboxylic acids and hydrohalic
acid
- Nucleophilic substitution reactions of acid anhydrides
- With alcohols to form ethers
- With ammonia and amines to form amides
- With water (hydrolysis) to form two carboxylic acids
- Nucleophilic substitution reactions of esters
- With ammonia and amines to form amides
- With water (hydrolysis) to form a carboxylic acid and an alcohol
- Nucleophilic substitution reactions of amides
- With water (hydrolysis) to form a carboxylic acid and an amine
|
|
|